Insurance carriers have suffered huge losses over the past 5 years due to a string of extreme weather events around the country and they are clawing back to profitability with higher insurance premiums and more selectivity on new insurance policies.
2024 has been an especially tough year for homeowners struggling to find comprehensive and affordable home insurance. In fact, 13% of real estate agents reported failed transactions due to insurance issues—up from just 7% last year, according to the California Association of Realtors’ 2024 Market Survey.
The following chart illustrates the growing concerns across the residential markets. Buyers of vacation or second homes are facing the biggest hurdles, with 51% reporting difficulty finding insurance in 2024. Rural buyers are also feeling the impact, as wildfire risks make insurers hesitant to offer new policies. This year, 45% of rural homebuyers struggled to secure coverage. Unfortunately, even city and suburban buyers aren’t immune to these challenges.
The situation in California’s insurance market is deteriorating each year, with former insurance chief and U.S. Rep. John Garamendi declaring it “in chaos.” Insurance companies point to strict regulations on rate increases, the escalating threat of natural disasters, and inflation as significant barriers to writing new policies. While the path to stabilizing the market remains contentious, California’s Insurance Commissioner, Ricardo Lara, believes that modernizing the FAIR plan—California’s last-resort insurance option—will provide much-needed stability.
To read more about this developing situation, check out a relevant article here.
Key Takeaways:
Real estate markets depend on reliable insurance coverage. A disruption in the insurance markets will affect home affordability and buyer confidence.
- If you already have home insurance, do what you can to keep it, as new policies may be harder to find and more expensive.
- Buyers should get an insurance quote before making an offer on a property or include an insurance contingency in their offer.
- Buyers should be ready for potential challenges in securing coverage and plan for longer search times.
Have you experienced issues with home insurance lately? I’d love to hear your story.
Warmly,
John