Complications with 1031 Exchanges

November 15, 2018

By Doug Goelz, Mortgage Services

With a 1031 Exchange, you sell one investment property and buy another, and you can defer taxes on gains from the sale as long as you follow the specific IRS 1031 rules.

Although lenders generally treat financing for a purchase in a 1031 Exchange the same as financing for any other investment property, you need to make sure your transaction meets the guidelines for both the 1031 Exchange and the lender. I recently had two clients in separate 1031 Exchanges where conditions acceptable or required by the 1031 Exchange rules complicated the financing.

One client sold her rental condo in San Francisco and bought a property with 2 units in Santa Cruz. The 2nd unit in Santa Cruz had a special restriction on it stating it could not be rented; it had to be occupied by the owner. This kind of restriction is unusual, but you may find such restrictions if you are looking at investment properties outside of the Bay Area. Of course, any restrictions such as this should be fully disclosed by the seller up front so the potential buyer can do their due diligence before making an offer.

The Santa Cruz property was eligible for a 1031 Exchange for tax purposes, but several lenders I spoke with balked at doing the financing because of the “owner‐occupancy” requirement on the second unit on the property. In the end, the client was able to get financing, but the pool of potential lenders was reduced and rates were not as competitive as they might have been had the property not had the occupancy restriction on the second unit.

Another client sold a property he had bought before he was married; the property was still in his name only when he sold. In order to get the full tax deferment, the 1031 Exchange rules required that the client be the only person on title for the new property, too. Some lenders would have allowed the client’s wife to be a co‐borrower on the loan for the new investment property without being on title, but they did not offer the most competitive rates

The client and his wife live in a nice home and have a mortgage and property taxes which they easily can afford on their combined incomes. Both the client and his wife are on title and the loan for their home.

The client decided to be sole borrower on the new rental property. As the sole borrower, lenders consider only the client’s income, but include 100% of the expense for the mortgage and property taxes of his current home (even though his wife is on title and shares responsibility for the mortgage) when calculating the qualifying debt‐to‐income ratios.

Fortunately, the client was able to get financing for his new rental on his income alone, but he did have to buy a lower‐priced property than he would have if he could have included his wife (and her income) on the new loan.

When you are considering a 1031 Exchange, be sure to talk to your lender about the financing so that you are not surprised by hurdles that could arise due to the 1031 Exchange. Want to talk about financing a 1031 Exchange? Feel free to get in touch with me at 415‐730‐4665 or [email protected] with your questions.

adminjs
Haven Group SF
Brokered by Compass

Buying or selling a home in San Francisco requires more than listings. We combine the market intelligence of The Haven Group with the global reach and technology of Compass.